05/18/12

The ‘Little Voice’-Dealing with Doubt

Shadow of a Doubt - S5isShadowDoubtWhile I try to keep all the content here at MusicEdMajor.net original in nature, there are times when someone else posts content that is so perfect for Music Education Majors that I choose to share it here on the site. This is one of those cases.

Over the past few weeks, I have had the pleasure of getting to meet Brian Wis (@teaching_music), a public school music teacher who has begun a blog entitled “Teaching Music in the 21st Century.” Brian recently posted an article that has particular significance to future music educators. The article focuses on what Brian calls “the Little Voice,” and the doubt it can plant in our minds as to whether music education is the right profession for all of us:

When it comes right down to it, being responsible for educating hundreds or even thousands of children over a career can be a scary proposition. Music education majors are so busy taking so many classes (for so little credit) that the future isn’t something they have had much time to think about. So I believe that there are periods of anxiety that arise whereby entering the profession feels completely wrong. We all went through it, in fact I’ve started to think that the more you’ve worried about it, the better teacher you might become. It’s ironic to say the least, but sensing the responsibility can seem too much to bear, yet being able to sense it is integral to becoming an effective teacher.

Brian goes on to discuss some of the reasons that this “Little Voice” seems so loud to many of us, and why we should not succumb to it. This is an issue that I know many future music educators deal with, myself included. I strongly encourage you check out the rest of Brian’s article, and the rest of his great posts:

Music Education Majors: Stifling The Little Voice [Teaching Music in the 21st Century]

Have you dealt with doubt before as a music education major? Have you gotten past it? If so, how? If not, what steps have you tried?

Related posts:

  1. Digital Immigrants: How Public Education is Playing Catch-Up With Technology
  2. 100 Music Education Majors Tweeting!
  3. Benefits of Drum Corps for a Music Education Major (Part 1/2)
  4. November Music Education Blog Carnival
  5. Music Education Blog Carnival – November 2011 Edition
About Andy Zweibel

Andy Zweibel is a Music Education major at the University of Miami Frost School of Music in Coral Gables, FL. He founded MusicEdMajor.net in June 2009, and has also been blogging at http://andyzweibel.com since the Fall of 2007. You can also find him on Twitter at @Zweibz7. In his free time, Andy enjoys spending time with friends, and exploring new technology.

  • http://nicklane.edublogs.org/ Nick Lane

    I have indeed dealt with doubt before. Before commencing my degree I was certain I was not cut out for it and it would be a pointless job – who cares (other than me) about creative arts subjects anymore!

    Now thankfully I have come to realise that creativity is what drives me – so there must be many other kids out there that have a similar passion for creating sounds. And if their aren't, I look forward to the challenge of creating enthusiasm in the kids.

    Teachers have it tough – there is a huge responsibility. I haven't been in a classroom yet so I don't know how my classroom management skills will go – that would be one of my doubts that I am working on.

    What steps have I taken: well I have practiced with some of my peers but of course they didn't have very many behavioral problems as they are adults.
    In one subject we have gone through possible scenarios that might occur – from the silly to the serious – and how to manage them.

    I'm pretty sure your questions were rhetorical – but I am interested to know what other people are thinking on this matter. Especially those that have been teaching music for many years

  • http://musicedmajor.net Andy Zweibel

    Nick, thanks so much for commenting! My questions were by no means rhetorical; I'm so glad you shared your thoughts, and I hope others share theirs as well.

    Practicing is a huge factor in preparation which can help ease any doubts that we might have. This probably explains why (as Brian mentions in his post) many of the doubts arise as students are preparing for their final semester and student teaching. Another great way to get experience with a more realistic group is to contact public school teachers around your college/university and ask if you can come in to observe. Chances are, as you observe more, you may have the opportunity to get some hands-on teaching experiences (sectionals, small groups, individually).

    Thanks so much for stopping by! I'm extremely glad you shared your thoughts on the topic :)